Performative Wokeness: A Response to MetalSucks

You ever get so immediately enraged with something you see, that your throat dries out and in the words of comedian Tom Segura “you forget to, you know, speak English words”.

Well, an editorial from MetalSucks.net came out yesterday and landed in my lap today and honestly I had to get up from my office chair and start pacing, partially out of second hand embarassment and the cringe factor and partially out of blind rage.

Now, I’m a lady identifying person, and I exist somewhere in the alternative thrift store goblin and heavy metal horror fan realms, which I’m sure you may have gathered, if you’ve been around DrunkInAGraveyard.com for a while.

I consider myself to be a reasonable feminist, sex worker inclusive and positive, trans inclusive, and identify as queer, disabled, a person of color, and neurodivergent. Before I created DIAG and began writing online, or podcasting, or sat down to film YouTube videos, I spent my time publishing zines, interviewing bands old school with a tape recorder, attending shows, doing college radio shows, and working in harm reduction. I got used to the vague ‘boys club’ mentality that came with the alternative scene, from drunk punx slamming into groups of women at church pew punk rock shows, to lecherous goth men with more makeup and pretension than their dates creepily quoting Byron to uninterested pigtailed lolita goths at Sisters of Mercy shows, to ‘woke’ hippie ravers with hemp and crystal necklaces preying on girls with dreadlocks so high on ketamine they couldn’t stand up.. the list is honestly never ending, and it’s echoed in all areas and walks of life. This universal experience is part of the driving force of the #MeToo movement which aimed to show the world that all women have faced some form of discrimination simply for existing in the identity of a woman (and yes, this includes trans women). It’s weird to type out that you get used to this behaviour.

And that’s where riot grrl came in, at least for me, that and kinderwhore – music by angry female identifying people, angry about being treated, like coat racks to hang the hopes and desires of toxic masculinity on. Riot Grrl brought me to zine making, button making, and radical punk rock, and it shaped so intensely my teenage identity within punk and later within goth circles. Even now, I still am unable to shake those punk rock roots. Riot Grrl was one of the driving forces behind creating Drunk In A Graveyard – the desire to see film and later music reviews from a perspective other than the standard white dude in v-neck t-shirt with glasses and a cold brew.

Part of what drove me away from review blogs in the first place is behaviour like I had previously mentioned – too many dudes, not enough ladies, not enough queerness, not enough of any viewpoint where I saw myself reflected. But I noticed something insidious begin to creep in, especially in the time of #MeToo, and it’s something I would like to refer to as ‘performative wokeness’.

Suddenly, it’s become quite in vogue for authors on twitter to put their pronouns in their twitter bios, work emails contain addendums about acknowledging First Nations territory, sites like MetalSucks write whole manifestos about refusing to work with or acknowledge the work of fascists, antifeminists, Nazis and other assholes within the metal scene or use their platform to cover the sexual assault allegations against Young and in the Way and yet, on June 6, 2019 they posted this article, which aside from being poorly written, not credited to any author and without the ability to leave any comments, is a horrifically misogynist comparison of various female stereotypes – aka the ‘goth gf’ to various subgenres of heavy metal.

In 2019, in the aftermath of #MeToo, in a time when everyone seems to cast a jaundiced eye on the phrase “female fronted”, is this really the time to be writing an article comparing your female dating fantasies to arguably shitty descriptions of music. Isn’t this ultimate objectification and dehumanization? Reducing women to stereotypes, while crowing about the need for diversity, writing articles about females in metal, and how important queer voices are… but oddly only rarely featuring queer voices, female voices, disabled voices.
I’ll tell you that I’ve pitched MetalSucks – a queer, disabled, female identifying person of color, and did not get a response, similarly so with two other female members of the DIAG staff.

No room for our voices, and yet, room for this article, which, while I’m assuming is a bad joke, is so tone deaf that I really wonder what the fuck is going on in this world. It’s come to my attention as well that this is likely a paid advertisement post for metalhead dating which is even more horrendous, and relates more to what I talk about a few paragraphs below, so keep reading.

Metal twitter lit up a few weeks ago when the Antifa Pope Richard was outed for having a twitter account alternate full of rape jokes, and he later went on to make tone deaf stickers that said “rape jokes aren’t funny” with the aim to donate this money to rape charities, again, something equally tone deaf.

Don’t get me twisted here – people have a right to be wrong, and this includes MetalSucks, and fuck, it includes me, because god knows I’ve made my share of mistakes. We all have a right to make our mistakes and learn from these mistakes, and do better, and sometimes, the best thing you can do when you’re wrong is to listen and it’s part of the reason I’m writing this post.

MetalSucks is no stranger to controversy – usually stirring up shit when they identify and lampoon (rightfully) the fascist prescence that exists within some aspects of the metal scene. Typically, I’m on their side whenever these seemingly endless facebook comment wars start up. However, I’m not on their side here. This behaviour is regressive, misogynistic and doesn’t exist within some elbow to the ribs hehe bro stuff vaccuum. This behaviour is harmful to the female identifying souls who exist or try to exist within alternative media, and within metal, because it normalizes the dehumanization and objectification of our bodies and our minds.

I am not a body, not your body, and I am not a sub genre of music, an album you get to dust off when you feel like playing it to impress your friends with how woke you are or with your awesome and obscure taste in music – with the truth being that you’d never listen to that record without an audience – and this is the ultimate metaphor for performative wokeness.

If you’re only woke when someone is watching, or it’s for clicks, to sell ad revenue, generate hype or hate, or sell something, then you aren’t really woke. You are wearing wokeness like a jacket, something to be taken off when you want to be comfortable, something to be shed.
And using female identifying people, and feminism as the coat rack on which to hang your wokeness is not acceptable. It was never acceptable and it isn’t acceptable now in 2019.

If your brand of feminism isn’t intersectional and doesn’t include queer, disabled, people of color, transwomen, and non binary people, and women you don’t wanna fuck or find attractive, then really, it ain’t shit.

I’m including some screenshots of the article in case it gets removed, which I’m hoping it does. Grant yourselves a mulligan and start over because you need to do better, and with the platform you have, there’s a lot of people listening.

A more humorous take on the MetalSucks advert/article/editorial exists over on Astral Noize and gender flips the original piece.

Following the publication of this article, on June 8, 2019, Vince Nielstein and the official Metalsucks.net twitter account took responsibility for the posting of the article and offered and apology with the promise that in the future, they would do better.
I’ve accepted this apology, and like many others, remain hesitant. The screenshots I took will remain on this site for reference.
But like I said in the article, we all have a right to be wrong, and MetalSucks has a big platform and should be prompted to use their microphone for good and I hope this is the case here.

Cover photo of Chelsea Wolfe taken by Robin @ Rickshaw Theatre in Vancouver, BC.
**********************************
You can find Robin on twitter.

Be sure to subscribe to our YouTube channel and like us on facebook, Instagram, and on Twitter.

Send us shmeckles on our Patreon.

6 responses to “Performative Wokeness: A Response to MetalSucks

  1. Pingback: If Men Were Metal Genres, This Is What They Would Be Like – Astral Noize·

  2. Pingback: If Men Were Metal Genres, This is what They Would Be Like – Richard Lowe's blog·

  3. Hello, lemme first start off by introducing myself.

    My name is Sean Wright and I am the sole-creator of Esoterica Codex blog. I’m sure you’ve heard about me via social media. I have also written for Noisey, ToiletOvHell, and Cvlt Nation(just to name a few). Hell I’ve even been quoted by BrooklynVegan. That’s just my writing credentials. Now onto my solidarity with you.

    I’m a realist. I’m also what someone who doesn’t know me would seem rather sketchy because of the blunt language that I use. But the truth is that I am with you, the writer Robin Goodfellow. I back you up 100% at most of what you find offensive with this showing of true colors by the staff of Metalsucks. You see about 3 years ago (well make that several years ago), I and a bunch of other commentors on Metalsucks had had enough with both Vince and Axl’s form of “wokeness” and saw it for what it is: fucking fake. These two idiots from Brooklyn parade themselves as “progressive liberals”, but when it comes down to it they are nothing more than typical CNN fanboys that try to hide their own frat toxic culture from their readers. In the end they somehow can’t not only fucking can’t keep their mouths shut but they do a terrible job at concealing their past sins with the VERY SAME language used by the so-called “oppressors.”

    I am writing all of this because it makes me happy inside to know that somehow in all of the madness that is engulfing the political social climate of the world today, whenever I see someone such as yourself seeing past their bullshit and calling them out for what they are there is at least some sort of sympathy between two different types of people coming from different walks of life: yourself and your background and me who comes from a rather southern, conservative military family who were pro-Reagan in the 80’s. Don’t worry I voted for Bernie in 2016 and will vote for Bernie and Tulsi Gabbard in 2020 so you don’t have to worry too much. But for two assholes to be all about shutting down and canceling and calling out musicians who are basically fuck-ups and are sooooo ‘outraged’ and ‘disgusted’ by sketchy fascist lyrics or views or god forbid one of them might be a conservative, they treat women and females like Motley Crue would do to their fans in the 80’s on the Sunset Strip.

    For two idiots who claim to be progressive liberals, they are anything but. I know I just repeated myself but it needs to be plastered all over the internet at this point. Metalsucks want pro gun ban? Fine take on all the rednecks, drug dealers, and gangs all you want and see how well they will comply. Metalsucks wants to legalize weed and possibly all drugs? Knock yourself out and indulge I say. Metalsucks want LGBT people having the same necessary human rights as miserable straight cis assholes who are in the closet? I’ve never been for exclusion when it comes to human rights. But all of that fake outrage goes down the drain when they claim to side with feminists and yet they have a LONG history of the most utterly sexist shit I have ever seen. More sexist than anything Trump can say at this point. What’s worst is again they try to hide it and yet they fail even at that. They even glamorized and wished it was the 2000’s when fucking George W. Bush was in office? Like he was any better by sending an entire generation to fight two endless wars based on oil and lies. Pardon me if I am wrong but I remember when even remotely showing support for George W. Bush at one point was what got you kick out of the lefty club. Prove me wrong on this one.

    The shitty part about all of this is that their shit fake take on progressive liberal values is what is going to drive people away from actual progressive liberal values. They can tackle music and claim this and that, but at this point they are only in it for the clicks likes and few dollars they get from being involved in the journalism/media. And they are doing nothing but divide Metal fans (both fans of sketchy music and not-so sketchy music) apart more so than the politcal and systematic oppressors they claim to be against. And if history has told us anything, that doesn’t always work out as planned.

    As far as concealing their previous sins, check out my blog article (https://esotericacodex.wordpress.com/2019/01/11/nails-and-metalsucks-the-battle-continues/) where I mentioned how they would post nudes of then female Winds Of Plague keyboardist and say even more sexist shit about other female musicians. Or fast-foward to the whole them calling out Nails frontman Todd Jones and they hinted and indicated that females are not allowed to listen to extreme music or wear band shirts. That’s just a couple of examples of evidence about your claim and your claim is nothing but fact at this point.

    So again, I’m glad you wrote this. You and I may not meet eye-to-eye on music(music is a subjective and personal thing IMO) but I can fully back you on using the very own tools they use against bad musicians with bad words and calling those two chodes out on THEIR bad words and plain ol’ horseshit. So I personally thank you for writing this. People think that this country is divided, I myself as an individual feel the opposite: we have more in common than what the internet tells us otherwise. Again, thank-you.

    • Here’s my real question as a 33yo husband & father who has been listening to metal since he was nine years old:

      How do I refuse to participate in the lame-ass “wOkE cULtUrE wAr” and still have some semblance of a “voice”?

      I see all of this bullshit for what it is and I’m not getting sucked into it.

  4. I’m proudly not woke, because woke is just the new, post-evangelical religion that deals in the same dogmatism & absurdities that it’s predecessor did.

Jimmies rustled? Wanna fight about it? Let us know why below!

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.